Loss prevention manager at Target punches woman police said stirred up altercation

BLUE ASH, Ohio — Surveillance footage from a Target in a suburb north of Cincinnati captured the moment a loss prevention manager punched a woman police said was instigating an altercation while requesting reparations for her purchase.

According to a Blue Ash Police Department incident report, Karen Ivery, 37, was charged with menacing and disorderly conduct, our news partner, WCPO-TV in Cincinnati, reported.

During the October 2022 altercation, Ivery said she wanted a portion of her Target purchase to be paid for as reparations. During the incident, a manager is seen on surveillance, which has no audio, punching Ivery once before police arrive.

According to an affidavit, Ivery allegedly caused the manager to fear for his safety.

The manager was never charged because police said he acted in self-defense.

Security footage shows Ivery arguing first with a Target employee near the checkout lanes. The employee continues to back up and attempts to stop Ivery by putting her hands against her shoulders.

Ivery “wanted to have a conversation about her bill,” which cost more than $1,000, according to the incident report. Target employees that spoke with police said Ivery claimed she was owed reparations and she wanted Target to supply those.

In the surveillance footage, the manager is then seen approaching Ivery. According to the police report, the manager asked Ivery to “calm down and leave the store,” but she began screaming at him. As Ivery continues to walk toward the manager, he is seen backing up toward his office.

The manager said he attempted to close his office door, according to the police report, but Ivery entered. The footage shows the manager punching her once in the face, with Ivery falling to the floor. He then calls 911.

In a report, police said that after watching the footage, they found Ivery to be the aggressor.

Ivery told police she wanted to have a bigger discussion about money and wanted Target to compensate her for the items she attempted to buy but could not afford.

“This is my Rosa Parks moment, dude,” Ivery said to the officer. “Don’t play with me.”

When a manager tells Ivery she is no longer allowed at Target, she becomes visibly upset.

As Ivery explains her frustrations to the officers, she is then told that she is being charged. When she is taken into custody, she claims that the officers are violating her rights as a human being in order to uphold the law.

Ivery was convicted of disorderly conduct but acquitted of menacing. She was sentenced to one day at the Hamilton County Justice Center.

©2023 Cox Media Group